One of the best days of the year on the Internet is the day after Halloween. That’s when Jimmy Kimmel posts his annual YouTube Challenge: “I Told My Kids I Ate Their Halloween Candy.”

If you’ve never watched one of these videos before, Jimmy Kimmel asks parents to prank their children by telling them they ate all their Halloween candy. The parents record their hilarious reactions and post them online. Jimmy takes the best ones and puts them in a compilation video that will have rolling on the floor.

Year after year, it never gets old.

How do you think this year matches up the previous years?